Welcome to Pizza Pantry
At Pizza Pantry, located in the quaint town of Corfu, NY, pizza passion runs deep. This hidden gem offers a mouthwatering variety of pizzas, subs, and hoagies, all crafted with care and quality ingredients. Praised for its friendly service, Pizza Pantry has quickly won over locals and travelers alike, emphasizing a welcoming atmosphere that feels like home. Their standout selections, such as the extraordinary turkey club sub and delectable white pizza, keep patrons coming back for more. With a focus on takeout convenience and a commitment to customer satisfaction, Pizza Pantry is a must-visit for anyone seeking delicious comfort food in a charming setting.
-
9468 Alleghany Rd, Corfu, NY 14036, United States Hotline: +1 585-599-4664
Welcome to Pizza Pantry, a charming culinary haven nestled in Corfu, NY. Located at 9468 Alleghany Rd, this delightful eatery brings comfort and flavor to the forefront, specializing in mouthwatering pizzas and subs. With a welcoming atmosphere and a dedicated staff, Pizza Pantry has emerged as a go-to destination for both locals and weary travelers alike.
At Pizza Pantry, the menu is a feast for the senses, featuring a variety of choices that promise to satisfy every craving. You can dive into their rich selection of pizzas—from a classic small cheese pizza to a party size option that’s perfect for gatherings. For those who prefer sandwiches, their hoagies, including the Steak Hoagie and Italian Sausage Hoagie, stand out at just $11.99. And let’s not forget the tempting sides like chicken fingers and those enticing pizza logs, ideal for sharing or indulging solo.
What truly sets Pizza Pantry apart is the heartwarming service. As echoed by satisfied customers like Hannah Hoch and Tee, the staff here go above and beyond, creating a friendly environment that feels like home. One glowing review highlights the employees’ kindness and willingness to accommodate special requests, like making an 'off menu' cheese sub for a vegetarian patron. It’s this attention to detail that transforms a simple meal into a memorable dining experience.
While the restaurant offers only a few tables—perfect for those who want to dine in the sun or enjoy a quick bite—most guests, like Achilles Sangster and Erika, rave about the take-out experience. The food preparation may take some time, but patrons agree it’s worth the wait for the deliciousness that awaits. As Matt Verdi put it, the white pizza is simply “AMAZING.”
If you’re planning a trip to nearby Darien Lake, make sure to swing by Pizza Pantry first. This little gem offers not just great food but a community vibe that is hard to find. Whether you’re hungry for a hearty sub or pizza with a perfectly crisp crust, Pizza Pantry promises to deliver. In the words of Alexis Scholes, the owner’s recommendations shine through, ensuring you’ll have a well-rounded and delicious meal.
So, whether you’re a local or passing through, stop by Pizza Pantry for a taste of their offerings, and you won’t be disappointed!
Great food and super friendly employees We just moved to the area and gave them a shot and ordered food and were not disappointed!! We would recommend anything on the meny
The pizza is great and so is the service! I'm glad we stopped here. Thats said, here are some FYIs for future travelers: it's kind of off the beaten path in a small town. We came expecting a sit-down place, but they only have three tables (one inside and two picnic tables outside); this place is mostly take-out. It took about 30 min for our pizza (we weren't in a hurry so this was fine with us). I overheard that they don't serve by the slice.
We got take-out tonight and it was delicious. The service was fantastic. It was super easy to call, order and pickup my food. My son is picky and he loved the chicken fingers and fries. My husband is always on the lookout for a good sub and he was happy with his sub. Update; I attended a private event here today and the service was amazing! The employees went above and beyond to help entertain the two little kids who were there. They also made sure everything was cleaned as we went and topped off. If you're looking for a nice place to have a gathering, this is it.
A little hidden gem, super close to Darien Lake. We grabbed food to put in our cooler so we wouldn't have to pay the crazy prices at the park. The subs were great. But, more than that, the workers were the kindest most helpful people I've ever come across at a pizza spot. The place was spotless. Loved it. They even made an 'off menu' cheese sub for our vegitarian.
I was passing through on my way to deliver a run to Georgia and wanted to try some local pizza. The wait was longer than expected but the place was slammed,so I understand. I got the white pizza and bbq chicken. The white pizza was AMAZING, the bbq chicken was also very good and they made it a large because I waited so long,also the owner is just good people. If im ever in the area agai I will be back.
Pizza Pantry is famous locally for a reason. They have my favorite subs ever. There is something EXTRA special about them. Their turkey club cannot be beat. The bread, meat, cheese... AMAZING. Their pizza and wings are always perfect as well. They have a really delicious crust. The owners are kind and friendly and you can't beat their prices. Order and you won't be disappointed
Very impressed with their food. friendly staff and the food was all very well made. We will definitely order from them again!
We had travelled to the area after a long road trip and this spot. We believe the owner waited on us at the register. When asked what he recommended, he was very helpful. Decided on a turkey sub, which was grilled to perfection and then two mini pizzas: one white, which did have fresh tomatoes, and a plain pizza.